Imagine a civilization as a structure held up by three pillars. Remove any one, and the structure collapses.
The first pillar is Power : the ability to act, to create, to execute. Without power, intentions remain fantasies. Ideas stay trapped in minds. Change becomes impossible.
The second pillar is Anchors : the grounding in culture, values, truth, and history. Without anchors, power becomes chaotic, manipulative, destructive. It accelerates toward fragility, not flourishing.
The third pillar is Builders : people capable of wielding power with wisdom. Without builders, you have tools but no one who can use them responsibly. You have potential but no agency.
In the agentic era, all three pillars are in flux. We are gaining unprecedented power through AI agents. But our anchors are weakening—epistemic chaos, institutional erosion, cultural amnesia. And we have not yet trained a generation of builders capable of steering this power.
This is the core diagnosis: We are accelerating pillar one while pillars two and three crumble.
The solution is not to slow down power. That's futile. The solution is to urgently strengthen anchors and builders—so that power becomes governable rather than catastrophic.
Let's examine each pillar, how they depend on one another, and what happens when any one is missing.
---
Pillar I: Power — The Arrival of Agentic Capability
Agentic AI represents the most significant expansion of human power since the industrial revolution—possibly since the invention of writing.
What Agents Provide
Agents collapse the loop from thought to execution:
- Completion engines: They turn fragments of ideas into structured arguments, plans, drafts, and prototypes.
- Cognitive prosthetics: They extend working memory, synthesize information, and enable rapid learning.
- Externalization tools: They make thinking visible and editable, transforming internal vagueness into testable artifacts.
- Execution assistants: They carry the heavy parts of creation—research, drafting, coding, organizing—so humans can focus on judgment and direction.
The result is a fundamental shift in the human condition:
In the past, most people were constrained by capability—access to knowledge, ability to write, time to execute.
Now, most people are constrained by orientation —clarity of values, depth of understanding, epistemic discipline, moral judgment.
What This Means
When power is cheap, three things happen:
1. Creation explodes: More essays, apps, proposals, campaigns, narratives, policies, designs, tools. The volume of output increases by orders of magnitude.
2. Quality diverges: Those who use agents wisely produce better work faster. Those who use them carelessly produce noise at scale.
3. The bottleneck shifts upward: The new scarcity is not execution, but judgment—knowing what to build, what to believe, what to prioritize, what to protect.
Power is the first pillar. It's necessary. But alone, it's dangerous.
---
Pillar II: Anchors — Culture, Values, and Truth
If power is the engine, anchors are the steering wheel and the brakes.
Anchors are the civilizational infrastructure that prevents power from becoming chaotic or predatory:
- Civilizational memory: The accumulated knowledge of what works and what fails across centuries.
- Cultural inheritance: The best that humanity has produced—art, philosophy, science, moral reasoning.
- Value literacy: Explicit commitments to dignity, truth, fairness, freedom, and responsibility.
- Epistemic discipline: The ability to distinguish truth from persuasion, evidence from narrative.
- Systems thinking: Understanding incentives, feedback loops, and second-order effects.
- Democratic maturity: The ability to govern collectively without descending into polarization or tyranny.
- Moral boundaries: Lines that must not be crossed, even when crossing them is effective or profitable.
Why Anchors Matter in the Agentic Era
Agents can produce infinite outputs. But they do not automatically know:
- What is true
- What is good
- What will scale safely
- What is worth building
Without anchors, agents become amplifiers of whatever the user already believes—including delusions, biases, and manipulations.
Without anchors, societies fragment into incompatible realities, each fluently argued and internally coherent but mutually exclusive.
Without anchors, acceleration becomes recklessness.
The Current Crisis: Weakening Anchors
Even as power grows, our anchors are eroding:
- Epistemic chaos: People increasingly live in separate information ecosystems. Truth becomes tribal.
- Institutional distrust: Faith in governments, media, science, and democracy is declining.
- Cultural amnesia: Historical knowledge fades. Civilizational memory weakens. Patterns repeat because they're forgotten.
- Value confusion: Relativism, cynicism, and nihilism replace coherent moral frameworks.
- Attention collapse: Constant distraction prevents the deep focus required for wisdom.
This is the danger: We are gaining power faster than we are strengthening grounding.
It's like handing a Formula 1 car to someone who has never driven. The engine is impressive. The crash is inevitable.
---
Pillar III: Builders — People Who Can Steer Power
Even if you have power and anchors, you need agents of action : people who can translate values into reality, who can use tools responsibly, who can act under uncertainty without becoming reckless or paralyzed.
This is what we mean by civilization builders.
What Builders Do
Builders bridge the gap between ideals and implementation. They:
- Formulate problems: Turn vague concerns into explicit, testable claims.
- Map systems: Understand incentives, stakeholders, feedback loops.
- Generate options: Propose multiple approaches, recognizing trade-offs.
- Test ideas: Build prototypes, measure outcomes, iterate.
- Accept accountability: Own failures, revise when wrong, act with transparency.
- Communicate clearly: Translate complexity for different audiences without distortion.
- Act with moral clarity: Maintain boundaries even under pressure.
Builders are not passive consumers or critics. They are active participants in the construction of reality.
Why Builders Are Rare
Most education systems do not train builders. They train:
- Information absorbers: People who memorize and repeat.
- Compliance followers: People who execute instructions.
- Credential collectors: People who optimize for grades and status.
- Critics: People who can identify problems but not solve them.
This made sense in a world where execution was expensive and most people couldn't act meaningfully. But in the agentic era, this produces:
- People with powerful tools but no discipline
- People who can generate outputs but not judge their quality
- People who react emotionally instead of reasoning structurally
- People who are easy to manipulate because they lack epistemic grounding
The result: power without wisdom.
The Urgent Need: Scaling Builder Formation
The agentic era demands that we train an entire generation to become civilization builders—at scale, systematically, starting in childhood.
This is not an elite program. It's a civilizational requirement.
Because when everyone has access to agentic power, the quality of civilization depends on the median level of judgment , not the excellence of the top 1%.
---
The Interdependence: Why All Three Pillars Must Stand
Each pillar alone is insufficient. Their power comes from how they reinforce one another.
Power Without Anchors = Chaos
Imagine a society with advanced agentic tools but no shared commitment to truth, dignity, or accountability.
What happens?
- Epistemic collapse: Everyone generates their own "evidence." Reality fragments.
- Manipulation at scale: Persuasion becomes cheap. Propaganda becomes personalized and irresistible.
- Institutional erosion: Trust disappears. Coordination fails. Democracy breaks.
- Cultural hollowing: Everything is produced, nothing is meaningful. Depth is replaced by noise.
This is the American trajectory if current trends continue: incredible capability, epistemic chaos, institutional fragility.
Power Without Builders = Capture by Elites
Imagine agentic tools exist, values are clear, but only a small elite knows how to use the tools responsibly.
What happens?
- Concentration of power: Those who can govern agents rule. Everyone else is governed.
- Passivity of the many: Most people remain consumers, spectators, subjects.
- Fragile legitimacy: The elite may be well-intentioned, but lack of broad participation makes the system brittle.
This is a technocracy: effective in the short term, illegitimate in the long term, vulnerable to collapse when the elite fails.
Anchors Without Power = Stagnation
Imagine a society with strong values, deep culture, and democratic maturity—but no ability to act.
What happens?
- Irrelevance: Other societies move faster. Influence shifts elsewhere.
- Frustration: Good intentions produce no results. Apathy grows.
- Capture: Eventually, those with power (elsewhere) impose their systems.
This is the European risk if it focuses only on regulation and values without investing in capability and education.
Builders Without Anchors = Naive Acceleration
Imagine a generation trained to act, to build, to execute—but without grounding in culture, truth, or moral clarity.
What happens?
- Well-meaning harm: People build systems that scale unintended consequences.
- Ideological capture: Builders become tools of whatever narrative they absorb first.
- Cynical optimization: Without values, builders optimize for profit, status, or power—not flourishing.
This is the Silicon Valley failure mode: highly capable, deeply naive about human nature and societal complexity.
Builders Without Power = Impotence
Imagine people trained in systems thinking, epistemic discipline, and moral clarity—but with no tools to act.
What happens?
- Paralysis by analysis: Endless critique, no prototypes.
- Elite gatekeeping: Only those with institutional access can implement.
- Disillusionment: Insight without agency leads to cynicism.
This was the pre-agent condition: many people could think clearly but couldn't translate thoughts into action.
---
The Ideal: All Three Pillars Strong
Now imagine a society where all three pillars are robust:
- Power is abundant: Agentic tools are accessible, well-designed, and widely distributed.
- Anchors are strong: Citizens are trained in epistemic discipline, grounded in culture and values, committed to truth and dignity.
- Builders are many: A large portion of the population sees itself as active participants in civilization-building, capable of formulating problems, proposing solutions, and acting responsibly.
What does this society look like?
Governance Transforms
- Citizens don't just vote—they deliberate, propose, prototype, and iterate policies.
- Institutions remain accountable because civic participation is competent, not just performative.
- Democracy becomes governance as collective problem-solving , not just elections.
Education Transforms
- Schools become arenas where students solve real problems, build real projects, develop real judgment.
- Learning shifts from absorbing information to governing cognition, from compliance to authorship.
- Students see themselves as builders by default.
Culture Transforms
- Creation becomes normal. Criticism is paired with construction.
- Public discourse improves because epistemic discipline is widespread.
- Manipulation becomes harder because citizens are trained to resist it.
Innovation Transforms
- Capability is paired with responsibility.
- New technologies are evaluated not only for profit but for civilizational impact.
- Speed is balanced with wisdom.
Trust Increases
- Institutions become more legitimate because participation is real.
- Coordination improves because shared epistemic standards exist.
- Societies become more resilient because they're not dependent on a small elite.
This is not utopia. It's simply a functional civilization in the age of agents.
---
The Work Ahead: Strengthening All Three
The agentic era gives us pillar one (power) by default. The market will ensure agents improve and proliferate.
Our responsibility is to urgently build pillars two and three:
Strengthen Anchors
- Invest in civic education: Epistemic discipline, democratic maturity, institutional literacy must become foundational.
- Revive cultural memory: History, philosophy, and the best of human achievement must be accessible and relevant.
- Establish ethical standards: Develop frameworks for responsible use of agentic power—at individual, institutional, and societal levels.
- Build truth infrastructure: Create systems that make evidence visible, uncertainty explicit, and manipulation costly.
Scale Builder Formation
- Transform education: From information transfer to governance training. From subjects to systems. From tests to real-world challenges.
- Train teachers: Equip educators to become coaches of reasoning, facilitators of arenas, and guardians of epistemic norms.
- Create pathways: Enable anyone—students, citizens, professionals—to see themselves as builders and access the tools to act.
- Measure what matters: Assess judgment, systems thinking, epistemic discipline, and moral clarity—not just knowledge recall.
Integrate All Three
- Design education systems where students use agentic power to solve real problems grounded in culture and values .
- Build civic institutions where citizens govern together using agentic tools and democratic maturity .
- Create cultures where speed is paired with wisdom , where capability is paired with responsibility , where innovation is paired with anchoring .
---
Conclusion: The Structure That Holds Civilization
The three pillars are not optional. They are not competing priorities. They are mutually dependent requirements.
Remove power, and you have stagnation.
Remove anchors, and you have chaos.
Remove builders, and you have capture.
The agentic era forces this choice:
We can build a civilization where power, anchors, and builders reinforce one another—producing a society that is capable, wise, and participatory.
Or we can allow power to grow while anchors weaken and builders remain rare—producing a society that is fast, fragile, and prone to collapse.
The choice is ours. But the window is closing.
The work is to build all three pillars—now.
---
Explore Further
Deep Dive: Power — Read the full breakdown of how agentic AI transforms human capability
→ [Link to Part I of Manifesto]
Deep Dive: Anchors — Explore the cultural and epistemic infrastructure required to steer power
→ [Link to Part II of Manifesto]
Deep Dive: Builders — Understand the education transformation required to train civilization builders
→ [Link to Part III of Manifesto]
Interactive Tool: What Happens When a Pillar Is Missing?
Explore scenarios showing the consequences of each failure mode
→ [Link to interactive tool]